First film – which render do you prefer?

I’ve uploaded the first film from yesterday.  Not for the project, but from the training.  The original render I was given was far too long for mobile upload, so I’ve tried re-rendering and uploading it through two different paths.  Comments welcome on them – I don’t even know what they look like until youtube has finished processing them.

Render 1 – Through Windows Live Moviemaker and uploaded directly from inside the programme to youtube.

Render 2 – Through Sony Vegas, and uploaded through youtube’s web interface